NESO's re-trading options are unlikely to do much for consumers
Batteries across GB have saved consumers £259m net since December 2024. That counts all energy trading batteries do: exporting into the wholesale market, Balancing Mechanism energy actions, charging to soak up constrained wind, and the cost of repetitive re-trading from batteries behind constraints.
We'll go through the numbers behind all of this in a later article. Today we're focusing on the costs of repetitive re-trading (RRT), which has been a focus in recent months. NESO is closing its consultation on storage behind constraints, with responses due on 26 November. Looking at NESO’s own analysis, it looks unlikely that any of the options it's proposing will benefit consumers much. Proposals could in fact end up costing consumers more, particularly considering the difficulty involved in implementation of some the options. This article looks at why, and explains how that aligns with Modo Energy’s view.
Read NESO’s consultation on RRT here, as well as Modo Energy’s previous analysis on the options NESO are looking at here.
NESO's consultation closes at 17:00 on Thursday 26 November. You can read it and respond here.
Need a quick refresher on NESO's options? If not, skip ahead to what NESO's numbers say.
Today, when a battery behind a constraint is scheduled to export, NESO bids it down (reversing the export). The battery keeps the energy, so it goes into the intraday wholesale market and sells it again. But the constraint is still active, so NESO must bid it down again. This loop continues as long as the constraint is active. That loop is repetitive re-trading.
3A, use non-storage actions first. NESO turns down other generation, mostly wind, before it touches storage. The battery isn't bid down, so its state of charge reduces as it exports, and there's nothing to re-trade. But this option also means NESO stops charging batteries and pumped hydro to soak up wind.
3AA, retain storage charging. The same as 3A for exports, but NESO keeps charging storage when that's the cheapest way to manage the constraint. If a storage unit is not exporting power, NESO can bid it down to a charging position. A battery NESO has charged can still sell that energy back into the wholesale market while the constraint is active.
3AA Max, targeted storage charging. NESO only charges storage when it expects the constraint to end soon, so if the battery sells that energy immediately in the next period, the constraint has cleared. NESO hasn't settled how it would do this.
What NESO's numbers say
NESO has published its cost-benefit analysis covering its three options, 3A, 3AA and 3AA Max. Each cell in the grid below is the change in 2025 balancing costs against today's approach.
The reason NESO gives a range rather than one number is that it has two assumptions baked into it.
The first is where replacement wholesale energy comes from. If you stop a battery re-trading, it exports less into the wholesale market. NESO assumes that energy is still needed, so another generator sells it instead. The range comes from how much of that energy comes from generators inside the constraint, and how much from generators outside it.
Sign up to read this article for free
Unlimited access to our free articles
Monthly access to 2 Global Research articles
Benchmarks, Forecasts, Ko and more





